By the CryptoToolPicker editorial team · Last checked · Fact-check log
Disclosure: links to providers on this page may be or become affiliate links. If you sign up through one, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes our picks. Affiliate disclosure
Prices and rules as of November 9, 2026 Checked against official pages on November 9, 2026. Prices and rules change; always confirm on the provider's own page before you pay.
Koinly sells a one time report per tax year: $49 for 100 transactions, $99 for 1,000 and $199 for 3,000, with no subscription. CoinTracker sells a yearly plan that renews automatically: $59 (100), $99 (250), $199 (1,000), $299 (2,500), $499 (10,000) and $999 (25,000), and one plan includes every past year's tax forms. For one recent year Koinly usually costs less, often by $100 at a few hundred trades. CoinTracker wins when you are catching up on several unfiled years, your first year is tiny enough for its $19 offer, most of your activity is staking rewards, or you want a 30 day refund window instead of 7.
Visit Koinly →Visit CoinTracker →
Not financial advice. This is a general, educational comparison of features and published fees. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any crypto asset. Crypto prices are volatile and you can lose money.
Jump to a section
- Koinly vs CoinTracker side by side (as of November 9, 2026)
- How much will each cost you? Worked examples
- Pricing questions people ask
- Counting rules decide your tier
- The timing catch: which year a CoinTracker plan unlocks
- Refunds: decide before you click generate or download
- Form 1099-DA: how each handles the new exchange forms
- Filing: TurboTax and other software
- Try both free before you pay
- Pros, cons and catches
- Who should pick which
- FAQ
- How we checked
- Sources
Koinly vs CoinTracker side by side (as of November 9, 2026)
| Koinly | CoinTracker | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes: every feature up to 10,000 transactions; pay for the tax report | Yes: portfolio and tax summary preview; tax forms need a paid plan |
| Starting price | $49 per tax year (100 transactions) | $59 a year (100 transactions); $19 first year if you qualify |
| Best for | One recent year at a time; active traders up to 3,000; paying once with no renewal | Several unfiled years; heavy stakers; TurboTax Online and H&R Block sync |
| Our pick | Koinly for a single recent year at almost every size we priced. CoinTracker if you owe forms for two or more years, your first year is very small, or rewards are most of your activity. | |
Prices and billing
Full table: prices and billing
| Koinly | CoinTracker | |
|---|---|---|
| How you pay | One time payment per tax year; never charged automatically | Yearly subscription that renews on the purchase date at the plan's current price |
| 100 transactions | $49 (Newbie) | $59 (Base) |
| 250 transactions | $99 (Hodler, up to 1,000) | $99 (Base+) |
| 1,000 transactions | $99 (Hodler) | $199 (Prime) |
| 2,500 transactions | $199 (Trader, up to 3,000) | $299 (Prime+) |
| 5,000 transactions | Set in the app: Not published as text1 | $499 (Ultra, up to 10,000) |
| Above 10,000 | Pro plan plus top ups of 1,000 transactions: Not published | $999 to 25,000 (Ultra+); higher volume plans from $1,999 |
| Past tax years | Bought separately, per tax year | Included in every paid plan |
| Changing plans | Upgrade and pay only the difference | Move up any time and pay the difference; move down at renewal |
| Discounts | None published | $19 Base intro offer for simple years; partner promos, first year only, not combinable |
| Pay with | Debit or credit card, or BTC, ETH, DAI, USDC | Major cards and digital wallets, or USDC priced in dollars |
- Koinly's pricing table lists Trader at 3,000 transactions and a Pro plan above 10,000; it does not publish a price in between.
Checked November 9, 2026 against koinly.io, cointracker.io and both companies' help centers, listed under Sources.
Counting, refunds and filing
Full table: counting, refunds and filing
| Koinly | CoinTracker | |
|---|---|---|
| What counts | Any deposit, withdrawal or trade you add; related transactions grouped and spam filtered | Transactions in the tax year you file only |
| Never counted | Spam (filtered automatically) | Spam and dust on every plan; referral rebates on paid plans |
| Staking and interest | Reward deposits count like any other transaction | Base and Base+: not counted until they reach $25 in proceeds for the year. Prime and up: never counted |
| Refund | 7 days, no questions asked, if you have not generated a tax report | 30 days, if you have not downloaded tax forms, reports or capital gains CSV files |
| Form 1099-DA | Upload each form or mark it Not received for every exchange before you download reports | Upload each PDF in its 1099-DA portal; three reporting options |
| TurboTax Online | PDF upload, one PDF per wallet | Direct sync, up to 1,000 capital gain or loss transactions |
| TurboTax Desktop | TXF file without the new 1099-DA boxes; or import through TurboTax Online | No sync: type section totals and mail Form 8453 with the statements |
| Other tax software | TaxACT export; FreeTaxUSA listed; no special H&R Block export | H&R Block integration |
| Cost basis methods | FIFO, LIFO, average cost and more; wallet based Spec ID | Method synced from Coinbase and Kraken; method by wallet and year on Ultra |
Checked November 9, 2026 against koinly.io, cointracker.io and both companies' help centers, listed under Sources.
How much will each cost you? Worked examples
The two companies bill different things. Koinly charges per tax year and counts deposits and withdrawals as well as trades. CoinTracker charges a yearly plan, counts only the year you are filing, and throws in past years. Here is what that means at realistic sizes, using each company's published tiers:
| Your situation | Koinly | CoinTracker | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| A first, tiny year: 30 buys and 4 sells, $450 of proceeds | $49 (Newbie) | $19 the first year (intro offer), then $59 if it renews | CoinTracker, by $30 in year one |
| A simple year: 40 buys and 3 sells, $2,000 of proceeds | $49 | $59 (Base) | Koinly, by $10 |
| An active year: 700 trades | $99 (Hodler) | $199 (Prime; Base+ stops at 250) | Koinly, by $100 |
| 2,400 trades | $199 (Trader) | $299 (Prime+) | Koinly, by $100 |
| 200 trades plus 2,000 staking rewards worth $400 | About 2,200 counted: $199 (Trader) | $199 (Prime: rewards never count, so 200 counted) | Tie at $199 |
| 5,000 trades | Set in the app, Not published as text | $499 (Ultra) | Check Koinly's checkout |
| Filing 2026 and catching up 2023, 2024 and 2025, about 100 a year | 4 reports at $49: $196 | $59 (Base), past years' forms included1 | CoinTracker, by $137 |
| 700 trades a year, three years in a row | $297 | $597 if Prime renews at today's price | Koinly, by $300 |
Checked November 9, 2026 against koinly.io, cointracker.io and both companies' help centers, listed under Sources.
- See the timing catch below for which tax year a CoinTracker purchase unlocks.
The examples assume each buy, sell and swap counts once and that the staking rewards are about $0.20 each. Koinly also counts the deposits and withdrawals you import, so frequent bank deposits or wallet moves can push it up a tier. Real counts depend on how each tool groups and classifies your data, so preview both free before you pay.
Pricing questions people ask
Is CoinTracker more expensive than Koinly?
For one recent tax year, usually yes: $59 vs $49 at 100 transactions, $199 vs $99 at 1,000, and $299 vs $199 at 2,500. The gap closes for heavy stakers, because CoinTracker's Prime plan ignores staking rewards while Koinly counts every reward deposit. It reverses when you owe forms for past years, since one CoinTracker plan covers them and Koinly charges for each year.
Does either one charge me again next year?
CoinTracker does: plans renew each year on the purchase date, on the same plan at its current price, which may differ from what you paid. You can turn off auto renewal in your subscription settings. Koinly says its plans are one time payments and it will never charge you automatically; you buy next year's report when you need it.
What if I go over my limit after paying?
Both let you upgrade and pay only the price difference. CoinTracker adds that you can move down a plan only at renewal. Koinly doesn't publish a downgrade option, so start with the smallest tier your free preview shows.
Counting rules decide your tier
Koinly counts any deposit, withdrawal or trade you add, then groups related transactions and filters spam, so its count is often lower than your raw export. A weekly recurring buy funded from your bank can mean two entries a week (the deposit and the buy), which is why a "small" year can cross 100. CoinTracker counts only the tax year you are filing, never counts spam and dust, never counts referral rebates on paid plans, and from Prime up never counts staking rewards or interest. On Base and Base+, rewards stop being free once they pass $25 in proceeds for the year. CoinTracker also lists a lifetime limit of 200,000 transactions on Base through Ultra.
The timing catch: which year a CoinTracker plan unlocks
CoinTracker says the time of year you buy decides which forms you get. Buy before your region's tax extension deadline (October 15 for the US) and you get the prior year's forms; buy after it and you get the tax year about to end. So a plan bought today, after October 15, 2026, is set up for the 2026 return, with past years' forms included. If you still owe a 2025 return, ask CoinTracker's support how that interacts before you pay. Koinly has no such catch: you buy the specific tax year you need.
Refunds: decide before you click generate or download
Koinly refunds in full within 7 days of purchase, no questions asked, but only if you haven't generated a tax report yet. CoinTracker refunds within 30 days, as long as you haven't downloaded tax forms, reports or capital gains CSV files. With either tool, the safe habit is the same: clean up your data in the free tier, check the count, and pay only when you are ready to file.
Form 1099-DA: how each handles the new exchange forms
In Koinly, the Tax Reports page has a 1099-DA Forms section listing every exchange that may have sent you one (self custody wallets like MetaMask are not listed). For each, you upload the form or click Not received. Koinly says you must finish this before downloading reports, or US forms such as Schedule D and Form 8949 can come out empty; it then fills in the right Form 8949 box (H, I, K or L) from your answers. Koinly also explains that small gaps against your exchange's totals are normal: it adds trade fees to the cost basis of what you receive, while some exchanges subtract them from proceeds, which can make its proceeds 0.25% to 0.50% higher.
In CoinTracker's 1099-DA portal you upload each PDF (under 20MB), confirm the numbers it reads, see them side by side with its own, and then pick Proceed as is, Adjust proceeds or Review transactions; it flags a recommended option. CoinTracker points out that an exchange only sees its own platform, so a 1099-DA can miss the cost basis of crypto you transferred in. Our Form 1099-DA guide explains every box.
Filing: TurboTax and other software
TurboTax Online. Koinly generates a TurboTax report with one PDF per wallet (split into parts above 900 disposals), which you upload one by one after choosing Enter a different way. For big histories it offers a totals only route: you type the section totals from its Form 8949 summary and attach the statement PDF. CoinTracker syncs straight into TurboTax Online, but TurboTax currently limits that import to 1,000 capital gain or loss transactions, and income such as staking always has to be typed in by hand.
TurboTax Desktop. Neither has a clean import. Koinly says TurboTax's TXF format can't carry the new 1099-DA boxes on Form 8949, so after importing its TXF file you edit every disposal, or you import into TurboTax Online first and then load that into Desktop. CoinTracker says Desktop doesn't sync at all: you enter sales section totals from its Form 8949 Attachment Pages, then mail Form 8453 with the statement pages within 3 business days of the IRS accepting your return.
Other software. Koinly lists exports to TurboTax and TaxACT and names FreeTaxUSA on its home page; for H&R Block it has no special export, so you copy figures from its IRS report. CoinTracker lists TurboTax and H&R Block integrations. Our TurboTax and crypto guide covers the TurboTax routes in detail, and Form 8949 for crypto explains the boxes.
Try both free before you pay
- Download a full transaction history (CSV) from every exchange you used, and list every wallet address you own.
- Import the same data into Koinly's free plan and CoinTracker's Free plan.
- In each, check that moves between your own wallets show as transfers, not sales, and fix any missing purchase history or missing cost basis warnings.
- Note the count each shows for the year you are filing, and compare it with the tiers above.
- If you owe past years, count how many Koinly reports you would need; CoinTracker includes them in one plan.
- Compare the net gain or loss each calculates. A big gap usually means missing or misclassified data, so find it before paying either.
- Upload each exchange's Form 1099-DA (or mark it Not received) and compare the proceeds with the form's summary page.
- Buy one: Koinly (one tax year, no renewal) or CoinTracker (check whether the $19 offer shows for you, and remember the plan renews yearly). Only then generate or download your forms.
Pros, cons and catches
Koinly
Pros
- Lower prices for one recent year ($49 at 100, $99 at 1,000, $199 at 3,000).
- One time payment per tax year; Koinly says it never charges automatically.
- Every feature free up to 10,000 transactions, including the capital gains preview.
- Accepts BTC, ETH, DAI and USDC as payment.
Cons
- Counts deposits and withdrawals, so frequent small activity costs more.
- Each past tax year is a separate purchase.
- No published price between 3,000 and 10,000 transactions, or above 10,000.
Catches
- The 7 day refund ends once you generate a report.
- TurboTax Desktop needs manual box edits, or a detour through TurboTax Online.
- No special H&R Block export.
CoinTracker
Pros
- One plan includes every past year's forms, and only the filing year counts.
- From Prime up, staking and interest never count; spam, dust and rebates never count on paid plans.
- 30 day refund before you download anything.
- Direct TurboTax Online sync and an H&R Block integration.
Cons
- Higher prices for one recent year ($59 vs $49 at 100; $199 vs $99 at 1,000).
- TurboTax Online sync is capped at 1,000 capital gain or loss transactions.
- No TurboTax Desktop sync.
Catches
- Plans renew yearly at the plan's current price, which may differ from what you paid.
- A purchase after October 15 unlocks the tax year about to end.
- The $19 offer is first year only and needs up to 100 transactions and under $600 of proceeds.
Who should pick which
Pick Koinly if you file one recent year at a time, trade actively up to a few thousand transactions, dislike subscriptions, or want to pay in crypto. Pick CoinTracker if you are catching up on two or more unfiled years, your first year is tiny (up to 100 transactions and under $600 of proceeds), most of your activity is staking rewards, you file with TurboTax Online or H&R Block and want a direct sync, or you want the longer refund window. Neither replaces a tax professional for unusual situations. Full details: Koinly review, CoinTracker review, Koinly vs CoinLedger, CoinTracker vs CoinLedger and the three way crypto tax software comparison.
Not tax advice. This is general, educational information about tools and IRS forms. Your situation may differ; ask a tax professional before you file.

Not sure? Take the 60-second quiz →
FAQ
Is Koinly or CoinTracker cheaper?
For one recent tax year Koinly is usually cheaper: $49 vs $59 at 100 transactions, $99 vs $199 at 1,000 and $199 vs $299 at 2,500. CoinTracker is cheaper when you need forms for several past years, because one CoinTracker plan includes them while Koinly charges per tax year, and in year one if you qualify for its $19 intro offer.
Does Koinly have a subscription?
No. Koinly says all of its plans are one time payments per tax year and it never charges automatically. CoinTracker plans renew each year on the purchase date at the plan's current price unless you turn off auto renewal.
Which has the better refund policy?
CoinTracker gives a longer window: 30 days, as long as you have not downloaded tax forms, reports or capital gains CSV files. Koinly refunds within 7 days, no questions asked, but only if you have not generated a tax report.
Do staking rewards count toward the limit?
On Koinly, reward deposits count like any other transaction. On CoinTracker Base and Base+, rewards don't count until they reach $25 in proceeds for the year, and from Prime up they never count.
Which works better with TurboTax?
CoinTracker syncs directly into TurboTax Online, up to 1,000 capital gain or loss transactions. Koinly gives you PDFs to upload, one per wallet, or a totals only route for large histories. Neither imports cleanly into TurboTax Desktop with the new 1099-DA boxes.
Do both handle Form 1099-DA?
Yes. Koinly asks you to upload each exchange's 1099-DA or mark it Not received before you download reports, then fills in the matching Form 8949 box. CoinTracker's 1099-DA portal reads each PDF, compares it with its own numbers and offers three reporting options.
Can I try both for free?
Yes. Koinly is free with every feature up to 10,000 transactions, and CoinTracker's Free plan shows a tax summary preview. You pay only to get the tax forms.
How we checked
Show how we checked this guide
On November 9, 2026 we read Koinly's pricing page and home page and three Koinly Help Center articles (filing with TurboTax, using Koinly with other tax software, and uploading 1099-DA forms), and CoinTracker's pricing page and six CoinTracker Help Center articles (plan pricing, the $19 intro offer, refund policy, the 1099-DA portal, TurboTax Online and TurboTax Desktop), and used only what they state. The worked examples are our arithmetic on each company's published tiers and counting rules; real counts depend on how your data is grouped and classified. Anything a company doesn't publish is marked "Not published". We did not buy a plan or file a return for this comparison, and nothing here is tax advice.
Sources
Show all 12 sources
- Koinly pricing koinly.io
- Koinly home page (features, 1099-DA and integrations) koinly.io
- Koinly Help Center: Filing using TurboTax support.koinly.io
- Koinly Help Center: How to use Koinly with TurboTax, TaxAct, etc. support.koinly.io
- Koinly Help Center: USA, uploading 1099-DA forms to Koinly support.koinly.io
- CoinTracker pricing www.cointracker.io
- CoinTracker Help Center: CoinTracker Personal plan pricing support.cointracker.com
- CoinTracker Help Center: $19 Base intro offer for simple tax years support.cointracker.com
- CoinTracker Help Center: CoinTracker refund policy support.cointracker.com
- CoinTracker Help Center: How to use the 1099-DA portal support.cointracker.com
- CoinTracker Help Center: File with CoinTracker and TurboTax Online support.cointracker.com
- CoinTracker Help Center: How to file with TurboTax Desktop support.cointracker.com
Everything above comes from these official pages as of November 9, 2026. Claims we couldn't confirm there are left out or marked "Not published".
